Review of Bay Street Tattoo Co.
Bay Street Tattoo Co. is a tattoo and piercing shop located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The shop offers a range of services, including custom tattoos, piercings, and jewelry sales. The shop is open Tuesday through Saturday from 10:00 am to 6:00 pm, and closed on Mondays and Sundays.
The shop has received a mix of positive and negative reviews from customers. Some customers have praised the shop for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, clean environment, and quality work. Customers have also appreciated the shop's attention to detail and willingness to work with them to create custom designs.
However, some customers have expressed frustration with the shop's communication and response time. Some customers have reported difficulty getting in touch with the shop to schedule appointments or inquire about specific services.
Despite these mixed reviews, Bay Street Tattoo Co. remains a popular choice for those seeking tattoos and piercings in the Milwaukee area. The shop's experienced artists and friendly staff create a welcoming environment for customers of all ages and backgrounds.
If you are looking for a tattoo or piercing, Bay Street Tattoo Co. is worth considering. However, it is recommended that you do your research and read reviews from other customers before making a final decision.
From the business
"Bay Street Tattoo has been tattooing and body piercing in Milwaukee since June of 1999. We are a women owned business and always have been. We are a custom tattoo shop and would love to draw you the tattoo of your dreams. Black & grey, color, or cover-up we are happy to help. The shop carries a large collection of body jewelry including genuine gemstones, gold, and acrylic of all styles. If you are looking for something and we don't carry it, we are happy to order it for you or make it to fit your needs. Give us a call or stop in today!"
Amenities
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- In-store shopping
Bay Street Tattoo Co. Reviews - 99
Add Review
Mr. LeBrun
I got my first tattoo done here with Walt! He was awesome. I highly recommend him for any line work you may be interested in, but he is talented in other areas, too!
He was easy to talk to and makes you feel comfortable in his presence. Will definitely be going back! Thanks Walt!
Liam Odden
I have been pierced a good amount of times in my life, and this has been, by far, the best of them all.
Thank you, Sheri!
Hannah Kaufman
I went in for a delicate flower tattoo under my collarbone and I had a great experience. I was immediately greeted by Sheri and she was super helpful and nice. The shop was super clean and cute. My tattoo artist was Walt and I couldn't recommend him enough. He was able to do exactly what I wanted and I know it required a lot of talent because the flower I wanted had such fine detail. He first drew a stencil of a picture I brought in and his drawing looked better than the picture I brought in. Before doing my tattoo he made sure it was exactly what I wanted and in the right place and made me feel comfortable the whole time. My tattoo turned out amazing. The lines are so delicate and the shading in the small flowers is beautiful. Walt is amazing! 10 out of 10 -would recommend this place!
Molly Van Beek
I got my nose pierced at a different place and it was starting to look very red and was starting to form a bump. I called Bay Street Tattoo and they were more than willing to let me come in to buy their cleaning solution even without an appointment. The woman I worked with there was so nice. It worked like a charm and my nose piercing is looking fabulous now after using this solution for a few weeks!
Amanda Lawrence
Sheri was literally the best piercer I have EVER had. So professional and knowledgeable and made everything go as smoothly and painless as a piercing can be. Highly recommend, and definitely will be back after my piercing heals up a bit :)
Michelle Bak
I can't speak to the tattoo aspect since I have no experience with that, but it's a great place for piercing. They were very knowledgeable, professional, and warm and friendly. We took my partner there to get their ears pierced (just the lobes, nothing fancy). The space is clean and pleasant and has a nice layout, with a couch and chairs for friends and family to sit while they wait. They also sell an all-natural cleanser to use to keep the earrings (or whatever) and the piercing itself clean while it heals. If I decide to get my ears pierced, I'm planning to go back there.
Sierra Lehman
Went in after a different tattoo place pierced my friends septum with way too big of a piercing. Sherri made us feel welcomed and comfortable, and even gave my friend a teddy bear to cuddle while she switched out the piercing! She explained to us everything she was doing before she did. I will definitely be coming back here with any piercing or tattoos & will be recommending this place to anyone in the future!
sophie m
My piercing experience here was great! They walked through everything I had to do with after care, answered all my questions, and were incredibly sweet. The pricing was very reasonable for cartilage piercings.
Edit: I have gotten a total of 7 piercings here now and everytime is amazing!! When the shop was closed once, I was going to get pierced at a different shop but ultimately walked out. The customer service is just too good at Bay Street, and the prices are great!
Sean McNaughtan
Walt did an incredible job on a mountain scene and porcupine tattoos. Really comfortable atmosphere too!
Shelbs K.
I got a cartilage piercing and it went so smoothly. She was so nice and helpful! She suggested a smaller barbell for another piercing I had and a great cleaning solution! I’ll definitely be back for my septum piercing!